The Witchery by S. Isabelle
I was clearly NOT paying attention at the beginning of this book because I completely missed the introduction to the characters and their powers. Whoops. Therefore, I spent a good portion of the book trying to figure out who was who and what they were doing. That really detracted from the story, which was my fault. But, the audiobook narrator was very robotic, so much so that I had to stop and check to make sure that it was an actual human and not AI. I know that this was YA, but it felt both very young and too old at the same time, which can be on brand for high schoolers. But, it hurt the flow of the story. Sometimes they acted more like they were in college than high school, then they would do something that reminded you they definitely were still teenagers. Logan was the most age appropriate character; she was confused about her powers, wanted to fit in, and found a boy she liked. We never really got any answers about Trent; who was he promised to? What kinds of powers does he have? It seemed like he was going to be the wolf boy, but he wasn't. That the witch that Iris saw as a mentor ended up being bad really messed her up, and is going to impact her relationship with Matthew. That his twin became a witch at the end of the book is interesting. I will listen to book 2, mostly to see if any of the unanswered questions get answered, but if it doesn't start pulling things together I will not be continuing.